Some quotes:
"Craftsmen suffer from mistreatment. Before we start to celebrate the making of things, this is something to keep in mind."
"The maker is always plural. We all know that we never make things alone, however, our experiences are not easily reconciled with current institutional models that rely so heavily on individual achievements."
"People regularly stop making things due to unemployment. In this way, let's acknowledge that affirmative maker culture is situated within a project-led and precarious economy."
[from "Theses on Making in the Digital Age" by Michael Dieter and Geert Lovink]
"...the development of adaptive, foundational skills... [to] empower people to manipulate the medium to their advantage and to handle unintended and unexpected problems when they arise."
"Schools manifest how they value a particular activity by building a space for it."
"Especially in low-income schools, students would often tell me that they used to 'make' and build things with their parents and friends... However that experience was disconnected from their school life, since they did not see a link between the intellectual work in the classroom and the manual labor in the wood shop. Because of bias inherent within the educational system their own forms of engineering and tinkering...were looked down upon by society and by themselves."
[from "Digital Fabrication and 'Making' in Education: The Democratization of Invention" by Paulo Blikstein]
It's funny how, as the semester comes to a close, so many loose threads of thought from all of my classes are starting to weave themselves together. I've been thinking for the last few weeks about critical pedagogy--how essential it is to think of whatever we are doing within its larger context. I've been reading about critical multiculturalism, critical history, and now critical maker culture.
One thing that has previously annoyed me about maker culture is what I perceived to be a kind of fanaticism. I tend to automatically distrust anything that people are are unequivocally praising, which is maybe not a good attitude to have, but I do feel more accepting of making and fabrication after these readings which did acknowledge some of the complexities surrounding the movement. My biggest complaint about maker culture was that I felt it failed to place any value on the making of things that didn't obviously connect to math or engineering--so it was good to see this same concern voiced in "Theses on Making in the Digital Age". I also worry about fabrication being hailed as the most democratizing technological advancement, when that's only true where fabrication labs are actually created. In rural and low-income areas, I worry that these spaces are not valued and therefor not built, which Blikstein also touches on. It's very validating for me to see my concerns shared by those who know more about making and fabrication than I do.
Another thread which has been weaving through many of my classes is an anxiety about actually being able to work with the populations I care most about in ways which are meaningful and effective. I want to work in a school where all of the faculty and administration are in agreement that art and technology are vital aspects of the curriculum. I want to work in a school where curriculum is integrated--art and tech play a role in every core subject (rather than core subjects being taught in the art classroom). Of course I want to work in a school with a Fabrication Lab and new media courses. But I want to work with kids in rural communities, where some schools feel lightyears behind and I just don't know if I can be the only person fighting for these things. It can be frustrating to look at examples of art programs successfully utilizing digital technology and know that these programs are privileged, and that these examples just will not be the reality for many schools.
"Craftsmen suffer from mistreatment. Before we start to celebrate the making of things, this is something to keep in mind."
"The maker is always plural. We all know that we never make things alone, however, our experiences are not easily reconciled with current institutional models that rely so heavily on individual achievements."
"People regularly stop making things due to unemployment. In this way, let's acknowledge that affirmative maker culture is situated within a project-led and precarious economy."
[from "Theses on Making in the Digital Age" by Michael Dieter and Geert Lovink]
"...the development of adaptive, foundational skills... [to] empower people to manipulate the medium to their advantage and to handle unintended and unexpected problems when they arise."
"Schools manifest how they value a particular activity by building a space for it."
"Especially in low-income schools, students would often tell me that they used to 'make' and build things with their parents and friends... However that experience was disconnected from their school life, since they did not see a link between the intellectual work in the classroom and the manual labor in the wood shop. Because of bias inherent within the educational system their own forms of engineering and tinkering...were looked down upon by society and by themselves."
[from "Digital Fabrication and 'Making' in Education: The Democratization of Invention" by Paulo Blikstein]
It's funny how, as the semester comes to a close, so many loose threads of thought from all of my classes are starting to weave themselves together. I've been thinking for the last few weeks about critical pedagogy--how essential it is to think of whatever we are doing within its larger context. I've been reading about critical multiculturalism, critical history, and now critical maker culture.
One thing that has previously annoyed me about maker culture is what I perceived to be a kind of fanaticism. I tend to automatically distrust anything that people are are unequivocally praising, which is maybe not a good attitude to have, but I do feel more accepting of making and fabrication after these readings which did acknowledge some of the complexities surrounding the movement. My biggest complaint about maker culture was that I felt it failed to place any value on the making of things that didn't obviously connect to math or engineering--so it was good to see this same concern voiced in "Theses on Making in the Digital Age". I also worry about fabrication being hailed as the most democratizing technological advancement, when that's only true where fabrication labs are actually created. In rural and low-income areas, I worry that these spaces are not valued and therefor not built, which Blikstein also touches on. It's very validating for me to see my concerns shared by those who know more about making and fabrication than I do.
Another thread which has been weaving through many of my classes is an anxiety about actually being able to work with the populations I care most about in ways which are meaningful and effective. I want to work in a school where all of the faculty and administration are in agreement that art and technology are vital aspects of the curriculum. I want to work in a school where curriculum is integrated--art and tech play a role in every core subject (rather than core subjects being taught in the art classroom). Of course I want to work in a school with a Fabrication Lab and new media courses. But I want to work with kids in rural communities, where some schools feel lightyears behind and I just don't know if I can be the only person fighting for these things. It can be frustrating to look at examples of art programs successfully utilizing digital technology and know that these programs are privileged, and that these examples just will not be the reality for many schools.
Comments
Post a Comment