This book was published in 2011, and I wonder what follow-up thoughts the authors might have now that almost 9 years have passed.
I don't disagree with the premise of this chapter, which is that our new networked infrastructure has fundamentally changed when, where, and how we learn. I might disagree with the assertion that "[The stories provided in this chapter] illustrate how the tools for learning in this new environment make the old way of learning and schooling seem much less effective." My first takeaway from this reading is illustrated by one of the example stories:
Sam, who has learned how to program using Scratch and whose learning has been elevated by the collective. In this example, the student learns just as much about community and citizenship as he does about programming. The authors express that Sam's most revealing comment about his experience was that what he looks for in other people's programs is something he would never have thought to do by himself. I don't know that I agree that the community Sam found online can't be constructed just as effectively in a classroom setting, or that having students learn from each other and support each other isn't something good teachers aren't already doing.
What all of these examples highlight for me is that it is absolutely essential to teach children how to use our new informational resources critically and responsibly. In the beginning of this chapter the authors list Facebook among some of the "potent new tools for learning"--in light of all that has come to light about Facebook recently I find this laughable. Again, I don't disagree that social platforms like Facebook or Reddit, content hosts like YouTube, and search engines like Google are tools with a powerful potential to enhance learning. But I do wonder what the authors would say now about Anti-Vaxx groups on Facebook or Incel subreddits.
[Arc-Of-Life Learning -- Douglas Thomas and John Seely Brown]
I don't disagree with the premise of this chapter, which is that our new networked infrastructure has fundamentally changed when, where, and how we learn. I might disagree with the assertion that "[The stories provided in this chapter] illustrate how the tools for learning in this new environment make the old way of learning and schooling seem much less effective." My first takeaway from this reading is illustrated by one of the example stories:
Sam, who has learned how to program using Scratch and whose learning has been elevated by the collective. In this example, the student learns just as much about community and citizenship as he does about programming. The authors express that Sam's most revealing comment about his experience was that what he looks for in other people's programs is something he would never have thought to do by himself. I don't know that I agree that the community Sam found online can't be constructed just as effectively in a classroom setting, or that having students learn from each other and support each other isn't something good teachers aren't already doing.
What all of these examples highlight for me is that it is absolutely essential to teach children how to use our new informational resources critically and responsibly. In the beginning of this chapter the authors list Facebook among some of the "potent new tools for learning"--in light of all that has come to light about Facebook recently I find this laughable. Again, I don't disagree that social platforms like Facebook or Reddit, content hosts like YouTube, and search engines like Google are tools with a powerful potential to enhance learning. But I do wonder what the authors would say now about Anti-Vaxx groups on Facebook or Incel subreddits.
[Arc-Of-Life Learning -- Douglas Thomas and John Seely Brown]
Comments
Post a Comment