Skip to main content

Assignment 07/03 - Impact25 Reflection









I started this project working with Jacqueline. Our initial plan was to do a digital, collaborative Flat Stanley, utilizing our mutual connection to Rochester as a foundation to build upon. Our first approach was to reach out to our contacts in Rochester and ask them to do a quick drawing of themselves, snap a picture of the drawing somewhere in the city, and send it back to us. As I began working on this a few complications and concerns came up: first, that I was having trouble coming up with 25 different, unrelated people to reach out to directly. Second, that most of my connections would be concentrated at the University of Rochester, meaning most of the images I got back would be of a very narrow slice of the city. I thought this was counter to our intent for the project, which was to build a diverse and unexpected look at a city we both already knew. 

With this in mind, I decided to alter my approach so that it would reach a wider audience while remaining consistent with our idea for the project. I decided to explore the idea of email chains, and I adapted my message to include a request that participants forward the project along. My hope with this approach was that I could reach out to a few trusted friends and colleagues in Rochester, each of whom had their own diverse networks, and let the project grow organically. I had hoped that this way I might get back unexpected responses, with new and interesting views of the city. 

This is the email form I sent out:


After a week of waiting, I had not received a single response. This, of course, made me EXTREMELY concerned. I had to examine what was causing this lack of response, after I had worked so hard to make my request simple, clear, and easy to complete. After talking with Dr. Jochum I realized that I had been structuring my request in a way that wasn't conducive to online communication. It should have been much more direct, as simple as "Here's what I need you to do, here is when I need you to do it, here is what I am using it for"--in that order. Maybe by including the project info first, I made it less clear and interesting for the recipients. Maybe the form made it too difficult to respond--recipients needed to be logged into a Google account to open the form and upload an image. This also meant that responses couldn't be anonymous, because I would have been notified of the person's name and email address when they submitted an image. 

Regardless of all this, there just wasn't time at that point to restructure the email request and send it back out. Additionally, it would have looked bad or been even more confusing to send this request out to the same people again. So I decided to re-think the project.

What I liked about the original idea was the opportunity for those involved to make something, and the opportunity to create a collaborative, digital map of a place. I decided to take a look at another popular classroom project, not so different from Flat Stanley--the Exquisite Corpse. In this final iteration of the Impact25 project, I took two approaches to gathering pieces for my Exquisite Corpse. First, I used my Instagram story to request that friends draw torsos for me. In my post I gave simple, clear instructions with examples. I was still holding on to the idea that I could include an element of uncertainty for myself--not knowing who would participate--but perhaps not shockingly, only one person responded (though this person had also asked a few coworkers to draw torsos, and sent me 3 drawings). After this epic failure I started reaching out to people directly. There were still a few who didn't participate, but for the most part I got back enthusiastic responses, with more than one other person unexpectedly including friends and coworkers. After putting all the pieces together to make a shareable GIF, I sent the final product back out to those who had responded (reactions posted above).

Mostly what I learned from this process was how to adapt, and to think about how we communicate online especially when asking for something. In my second attempt I really thought that I had made my request more direct and effective, but I'll have to think more about what went wrong there. Overall I'm happy with the final product that came out of this collaboration between myself, good friends, acquaintances, and even strangers, and I think it was so nice to be able to share it with them at the end.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Assignment 2/1 - Netiquette

All things I’m working on - disengaging from emails, experiencing the moment, taking time to process

Assignment 4/3

I have complicated feelings about digital photography as a medium, especially as it relates to education. On the one hand, I think it's dangerously easy to use digital photography as a shortcut and circumvent learning about image-making--how the camera works, how to manipulate outcomes, and how to compose thoughtfully and purposefully. I'm thinking about how precious photographs used to be, when you only had so many shots available and this limitation made you feel that every time you pressed the shutter, it had to be just right. For this reason I've always toyed with the idea of using disposable cameras in my classroom, as a relatively cost-effective way to teach children these concepts. I've never even thought about how I might use digital photography in the classroom, because I'm concerned about how children learn to make images and how they learn to look at the world. On the other hand, digital photography can still be a valuable tool in artistic practice and ...

Assignment 1/1 - About Me - pt.1

Hey! My name is Emma, and I'm excited to start this blog as a digital journal for the semester. About me:  I graduated from the University of Rochester in 2018 with a BA in Studio Art. The program was very small, so we didn't have specialties or concentrations--some people chose to focus on one medium anyway, but I ended up trying lots of different things. I'm a multi-media artist through and through, and exploring media and materials is a huge part of my practice. That being said, my experience with new media and technology is fairly limited--most of my experience is with traditional media like painting, printmaking, and bookmaking. I'm very comfortable with a digital camera, and I do some digital illustration/painting. In school I took classes in animation (using Blender) and programming in Python. I have some experience in video and audio, and I did a project once with glitch art which was a  nightmare  but the result was pretty good. So overall I have a pretty b...